Tried & Tested: Socks
To the lovers of wild patterns and unconventional color-blocking, we see you, we appreciate you, but this post is not for you. This post is for folks like myself who prefer the most basic of basics when it comes to socks: the solid crew.
Darn Tough “Standard Crew” ~$25/pair
If you’re short on time, you could stop reading here and you’d be set with a solid sock for life. Darn Tough socks, in any weight, are famous for their durability and comfort. They may come at a slightly higher price point than we’re used to paying for socks, but they are worth it and we’re not alone in this belief. The Darn Tough brand is consistently among the highest regarded sock-makers in the world, their products are guaranteed for life, and they are produced right here in Vermont.
Pros:
- Seamless toe
- Unbeatable comfort and build quality
- Unconditionally guaranteed for life
Cons:
- Price, but the best example of “you get what you pay for”
The Railroad Sock ~$3/pair
This is as close as you can get to a Hanes-level deal in terms of per-pair pricing. Incredibly affordable with incredibly passable quality given the low cost. Are they the best socks in the world? No. But if you are looking for cheap, American-made alternatives to big-box socks, The Railroad Sock deserves a look.
Pros:
- Very budget-friendly
- Huge variety of mixed packs available
Cons:
- General quality drop-off, but again, “you get what you pay for”
- Seam along the toe
Harvest & Mill ~$14/pair
If you’re interested in organic materials and natural dyes, look no further than the Harvest & Mill Organic Cotton Crew. The organic cotton is grown in the USA, spun here, and knit here, as well. In this particular example, the plant fiber is naturally brown, but they also come in natural white and natural tan-green.
Pros:
- Certified carbon neutral product
- Dye-free, organic cotton construction
- Color intensifies with time and washes
Cons:
- Limited color selection
- Seam along the toe
Fox River “Heavyweight Crew” ~$18/pair
Fox River makes a great sock, plain and simple. They may not get as much attention as Darn Tough, but their design selection and build quality is competitive enough, in our opinion. If you love the hunt and need more options when it comes to topping off your sock collection, include Fox River in your rotation.
Pros:
- Great comfort and build quality
- Smooth, flat comfort toe seam
Cons:
- Moderate pilling with age
Wigwam “Super 60® Crew” ~$7/pair
For me, they are the best American-made sock within the "affordable" category. They hold up better than The Railroad Sock, not as well as pricier options, but still a great sock for the money.
Pros:
- Good blend of quality and price
- Large variety of colors and heights available
Cons:
- Seam along the toe
To wrap things up, it’s worth clarifying: we have not tested every American-made sock on the market. We’d love to, and we’re working our way through each brand as needs arise, but for now we can only discuss the products we are most familiar with.
If you have a favorite American-made sock that we don’t currently feature on the index, shoot us a note here and we’ll do our best to try them out.